Personal Identity in Five Questions

 

Philosophers have been working since the dawn of time to determine the meaning of life, to understand the purpose of human existence.  We’ll leave the existential questions to the philosophers.  Let’s tackle something slightly less complex (but still perplexing at times).  Seeking and finding personal identity be an exhausting quest.  It requires some reflection and meaningful deliberation, but identity can effectively be boiled down to five questions.

What’s your name?

What’s title best describes your role?

What larger community do you affiliate yourself with?

What pain has shaped you?

What’s achievement or value drives you through life?

Full disclosure – I pulled these questions from a movie, Glatiador (2001).  As you can see in the text below, Maximus states his name, his professional titles in the military.  He pledges his allegiance to Marcus Aurelius then describes the trauma he has suffered before proclaiming his primary mission in life is vengeance*.

My name is Maximus Decimus Meridius, Commander of the Armies of the North, General of the Felix Legions, loyal servant to the true emperor, Marcus Aurelius. Father to a murdered son, husband to a murdered wife, and I will have my vengeance, in this life or the next.

The video provides context for the scene, making it clear that Maximus, by sharing his personal identity, has literally put his life at risk.  His titles, affiliations, traumas, and his purpose put him at risk to be murdered.  Even now, there are people that put themselves in harms way when sharing their authentic identity. Associating with certain religions, sexual orientations, and beliefs can (and does) put people of risk of being assaulted and killed in some situations.

 

Even if you won’t be physically harmed, professing affiliations and core motivations leaves you at risk.  To be authentic is to be vulnerable.  You make yourself vulnerable to social judgement, ridicule, and marginalization. People can use your pain and ambitions to manipulate or hurt you.  While these risks are real, there is great value in sharing your authentic self.

Without embracing your identity, without sharing it with others, it becomes almost impossible to cultivate genuine social connections.  Relationships remain superficial until both people involved are vulnerable and authentic.  The five questions listed above are important for understanding yourself, but the answers become infinitely more powerful when you gain the courage to share them with the people around you.  Could you share that identity with your friends?  Your family?  Your coworkers? A stranger on the street?  A stadium full of people?  To share yourself completely is to accept completely and to trust completely.  Are you ready for that?

*Revenge is an extremely popular plot device; however, it rarely leads to healthy mental and emotional functioning outside of these fictional stories.

All the Best Movies are Love Stories

I’m a big fan of movies.  I like watching them, reading about them, talking about them, and analyzing them.  As much as possible, I revel in the movie watching experience.  At home it’s about popping popcorn, turning down the lights, and getting comfortable.  If I’m fortunate enough to get out of the house and go to the theater, the complete experience includes popcorn(no “butter”), Hot Tamales, and an ice cold drink.  I get to the theater early so I can pick the seat I want, and I wait with anticipation for the first trailers to flash onto the big screen.

I’m thoroughly and completely engrossed in all things cinema, and that’s why I love to ask people about the movies that mean the most to them.  I’ve gone beyond the “favorite movie” question.  It’s not a fair question.  There are too many considerations for anyone to genuinely identify a single favorite movie.  I’ve taken to asking a variation of the question that gets more directly to the things I want to know about.

“If you were stuck on a desert island and could only watch one movie for the rest of your life, what would it be and why?”

This question requires a level of commitment to a movie.  It calls for identification of the most compelling aspects of a film.  It eliminates the movies that are good the first time, then lose steam.  It dismisses movies that are perfect for particular moments or situations, but can’t be counted on under unknown circumstances.  To pick a movie you can be entertained by for the rest of your life goes beyond favorites and gets to genuine connection.

For more than a decade, my own answer to this question has been the same.  I passionately answer, “The Princess Bride.”

The movie strikes the perfect notes, delivering anything and everything I might need in the movie-watching experience.  Romance?  Got it.  Adventure?  Got it.  Revenge? Got it.  Mystery?  Got it.  Friendship?  Got it.  Courage, mortality, humor, conviction, sacrifice, magic, mercy, compassion, swords, morality, underdogs, sarcasm, surprise, villians, heroes, giants, and a battle of wits?  Got it.  It’s a movie that I can quote, and often do.  It’s a movie I’ve watched with my parents, my wife, my kids, and many of my best friends over the years.  There are moments of distress, suspense, fear, sadness, and pain, but it never dwells there.  The idea that love and hope can overcome hate, greed, and deceit flows through the entire story.

Not everyone would pick “The Princess Bride” as their desert island movie, but I’ll firmly claim that any movie they choose will be built on the foundations of love and hope.  In fact, all the best movies are love stories.  Neo only understands The Matrix after Trinity confesses her love for him.  William Wallace would have been a humble farmer had the love of his life been spared.  If Anakin doesn’t love his son, maybe the force never awakens.  Andy loves Woody and Woody loves Andy.  Steve Rogers loves his friends and his country.  Maximus Decimus Meridius, driven by the love of his family, brought down an emperor.  Jon McClane couldn’t let anything happen to his wife and ended up thwarting several major terrorist attacks.  Django’s love never faded despite time and distance.  Clarence would have faced any danger for Alabama.  Love story after love story.  Not all of them are romances, but they’re definitely love stories.

I’ve never watched enjoyed a movie that didn’t root itself in some type of love.  Some are more covert than others, but I promise you – your favorite movie is a love story.  If you’re convinced, you may be asking why?  Well, it’s really quite obvious.  The human experience is given meaning through relationships, and the connections we build allow us to flourish in life.  There is no better motivator, nothing more fulfilling, no emotion stronger than love, the unwavering commitment to a relationship.  When films allow us to witness that, and to relive it, or imagine ourselves driven by the same connections, we can’t help feeling enthralled.

So…what movie would you watch if you were stranded on a desert island? Why.